A committee that meets every month has the same chair, the same treasurer and mostly the same members each time. Yet many minute-takers still open each new transcript to “Speaker 1, Speaker 2, Speaker 3” and type the names in again. Otter.ai and Fireflies.ai are two of the most widely used tools. If your meetings mix Cantonese and English, check each tool’s current language list first, then compare every candidate on how it handles the same people meeting after meeting.
What should you compare for recurring meetings?
Compare Otter.ai, Fireflies.ai and any alternative on four points:
| What to compare | Why it matters for a recurring committee |
|---|---|
| Separating voices | Each member gets their own label, even when two people share a microphone |
| Naming once | You type a name once and it applies across the whole transcript |
| How far names carry | Whether a name you set is recognised in the next meeting, and in which meetings exactly |
| Spot-checking | You can jump to everything one person said and confirm it was really them |
The third point needs a precise answer. “Remembers speakers” can mean different things in different tools, so read the documentation and find out which recordings a saved name applies to.
How do you test a tool across two meetings?
Use two real meetings of the same committee, with the members’ permission:
- Transcribe the first meeting and name every speaker.
- Check one person’s lines by jumping to everything they said.
- Transcribe the second meeting in the same place, such as the same folder or project.
- Count the names you had to type again, and the labels that went to the wrong person.
- Read three lines in Cantonese and English to check the language came out as spoken.
The tool that leaves you the fewest names to fix in meeting two is the best fit for a recurring committee. For a broader scorecard, see our guide to choosing an AI meeting-notes tool in Hong Kong.
How does Oak handle familiar speakers?
Oak is built for Hong Kong’s mixed Cantonese and English, with 94%+ accuracy on real, mixed-language Cantonese. For recurring meetings, the unit is the project.
- Give each committee its own project. Put every meeting of the finance committee in one project, and every meeting of the board in another.
- Separate: Oak splits the recording by voice and labels Speaker 1, 2, 3, including different people sharing one microphone.
- Name once: rename Speaker 2 to “Peter” and the name applies across the whole transcript. Bulk rename is available.
- Next meeting, same project: Voice Memory recognises Peter in later recordings in the same project, so the names are already there.
- Spot-check: jump to every place one speaker talks, and play any sentence to confirm who said it.
Bring meetings in with Oak Bot for Google Meet, Zoom or Microsoft Teams, live recording in the browser for in-person meetings, or upload.
Frequently asked questions
Can members choose not to have their voice remembered?
Yes. A speaker’s voice profile stays in your account, and each speaker can opt out at any time.
What if a new member joins?
Name them once in their first meeting. In later recordings in the same project, Voice Memory recognises them too.
Is there a free trial?
Yes. Oak has a 7-day free trial. See the current plans and trial details.
Name your committee once per project. Start for Free — see plans and trial details and run the two-meeting test with Oak.